2009 — Tri-Valley 2, Pine Grove 1
2010 — Pine Grove 2, Minersville 1
2011 — None (canceled, rain)
2012
Semifinals
Pine Grove 2, Williams Valley 0
Pottsville 10, Marian 1
Championship — Pine Grove 7, Pottsville 6
2013
Semifinals
Pine Grove 12, Mahanoy Area 0, 5 inn.
Tri-Valley 6, Pottsville 5, 9 inn.
Championship — Tri-Valley 3, Pine Grove 2
2014
Semifinals
Williams Valley 8, North Schuylkill 2
Pottsville 10, Marian 2
Championship — Williams Valley 5, Pottsville 3, 8 inn.
2015
Semifinals
Tamaqua 6, Tri-Valley 5, 11 inn.
Pottsville 5, Marian 1
Championship — Pottsville 5, Tamaqua 3
NOTE: League playoffs restarted in 2009. Semifinal round added in 2011.